Investing in fixed-income securities like Non-Convertible Debentures “NCDs” and Bonds is a common strategy for those seeking stable returns. However, their safety levels is vary based on factors such as the issuer credibility, collateral backing, credit ratings, & market liquidity.

Issuer Credibility

NCDs are issued by companies to raise the capital. Their security depends on the financial health of the company that issues. Some NCDs are safe, which means that they are supported by the company's property, which provides the security level. However, uncertain NCDs take high risk as they are the not supported by security. Contrary to this, bonds, especially government and PSU bonds, are the considered safe because they are supported by the government or well as the established institutions, making them more reliable investments.

Credit Ratings and Risk Assessment

Credit assessments play an important role in assessing the safety of both NCD and Bond. Agencies such as Crisil, ICRA and care provide rankings that indicate the level of risk. Highly assessed NCDs (AAA or AA) indicate low risk, while low-classified default is most likely. Government bonds usually have the highest security assessments, making them a favourite option for conservative investors.

Liquidity Factor

Liquidity is another important factor to consider liquidity. Government and PSU bonds are more fluid and can easily be translated into the secondary market. Conversely, NCD may have low liquidity depending on the demand and issuer reputation, which may affect the investor's ability to get out of the investment quickly.

Default Risk

Unsecured NCDs pose a higher risk company can withstand financial problems, it poses a highly risk of default. There is less probability of defaulting stable companies or bonds issued by the government, making them a safe investment alternative.

Key Differences Between NCDs and Bonds

• Security: Government bonds are generally more secure than corporate NCDs.
• Returns: NCDs often provide higher returns than bonds due to increased risk.
• Liquidity: Bonds are more liquid and easier to trade in the secondary market.
• Default Risk: Unsecured NCDs have a higher default risk than government-backed bonds.
• Investment Purpose: Bonds are ideal for conservative investors, while NCDs suit those seeking higher returns with manageable risk.

Conclusion

If security is prioritized, government and PSU bonds are the best options. NCDs can offer high returns, but come with different degrees of risk. Investors should carefully consider the relationship between risk-inam before decisions between NCDs and bonds to ensure a balanced investment portfolio.

Read Also 

Convertible Bond
Is it safe to invest in NCD