Compare Strategies
| THE COLLAR | SHORT GUTS | |
|---|---|---|
|   |   | |
| About Strategy | The Collar Option StrategyCollar Strategy is an extension to Covered Call Strategy. A trader, who is bullish in nature but has a very low risk appetite and wants to mitigate his risk will implement the Collar Strategy. Collar involves buying of stock in either Cash/Futures Market, buying an ATM Put Option & selling an OTM Call Option. The expiry dates of the op                                         | Short Guts Option StrategyThis strategy is implemented by a trader when he is neutral on the movements and bearish on volatility i.e. he expects the stock to be range bound in the near future. This strategy involves sale of 1 ITM Call Option and 1 ITM Put Option. This strategy can be called as Credit Spread since his account is credited at the time of entering in the positions. <                                        .. | 
THE COLLAR Vs SHORT GUTS - Details
| THE COLLAR | SHORT GUTS | |
|---|---|---|
| Market View | Bullish | Neutral | 
| Type (CE/PE) | CE (Call Option) + PE (Put Option) + Underlying | CE (Call Option) + PE (Put Option) | 
| Number Of Positions | 3 | 2 | 
| Strategy Level | Advance | Beginners | 
| Reward Profile | Limited | Limited | 
| Risk Profile | Limited | Unlimited | 
| Breakeven Point | Price of Features - Call Premium + Put Premium | Upper Breakeven Point = Net Premium Received + Strike Price of Short Call, Lower Breakeven Point = Strike Price of Short Put - Net Premium Received | 
THE COLLAR Vs SHORT GUTS - When & How to use ?
| THE COLLAR | SHORT GUTS | |
|---|---|---|
| Market View | Bullish | Neutral | 
| When to use? | It should be used only in case where trader is certain about the bearish market view. | This strategy is implemented by a trader when he is neutral on the movements and bearish on volatility i.e. he expects the stock to be range bound in the near future. | 
| Action | Buy Underlying, Buy 1 ATM Put Option, Sell 1 OTM Call Option | Sell 1 ITM Call, Sell 1 ITM Put | 
| Breakeven Point | Price of Features - Call Premium + Put Premium | Upper Breakeven Point = Net Premium Received + Strike Price of Short Call, Lower Breakeven Point = Strike Price of Short Put - Net Premium Received | 
THE COLLAR Vs SHORT GUTS - Risk & Reward
| THE COLLAR | SHORT GUTS | |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum Profit Scenario | Strike Price of Short Call - Purchase Price of Underlying + Net Premium Received | Net Premium Received + Strike Price of Short Put - Strike Price of Short Call - Commissions Paid | 
| Maximum Loss Scenario | Purchase Price of Underlying - Strike Price of Long Put - Net Premium Received | Price of Underlying - Strike Price of Short Call - Net Premium Received OR Strike Price of Short Put - Price of Underlying - Net Premium Received + Commissions Paid | 
| Risk | Limited | Unlimited | 
| Reward | Limited | Limited | 
THE COLLAR Vs SHORT GUTS - Strategy Pros & Cons
| THE COLLAR | SHORT GUTS | |
|---|---|---|
| Similar Strategies | Call Spread, Bull Put Spread | Short Strangle (Sell Strangle), Short Straddle (Sell Straddle) | 
| Disadvantage | • Limited profit. • A trader can book more profit without this strategy if the prices goes high. | • Unlimited potential loss if the underlying stock continues to move in one direction. • High margin required. | 
| Advantages | • This strategy protects the losses on underlying asset. • Risk gets limited if the price of the stocks goes down. • Trader can get ownership benefits life dividend and voting rights. | • Ability to profit even when underlying asset stays stagnant. • You are already paid your full profit the moment the position is put on as this is a credit spread position. • Higher chance of ending in full profit as compared to short strangle or short straddle. |