Compare Strategies
PROTECTIVE COLLAR | SHORT PUT BUTTERFLY | |
---|---|---|
![]() |
![]() |
|
About Strategy |
Protective Collar Strategy This Strategy is implemented when the investor requires downside protection for the short - to medium term but at lower cost. Buying protective puts can be an expensive proposition and writing OTM calls can defray the cost of the puts quite substantially. Protective Collar is considered as bearish to neutral strategy. In this strategy risk and reward is both are limited. This |
Short Put Butterfly Option StrategyIn Short Put Butterfly strategy, a trader is neutral in nature and expects the market to remain range bound in the near future. A trader will buy 2 ATM Put Options; sell 1 ITM & 1 OTM Put Options. Here risk and returns both are limited. Risk:< .. |
PROTECTIVE COLLAR Vs SHORT PUT BUTTERFLY - Details
PROTECTIVE COLLAR | SHORT PUT BUTTERFLY | |
---|---|---|
Market View | Neutral | Neutral |
Type (CE/PE) | CE (Call Option) + PE (Put Option) | PE (Put Option) |
Number Of Positions | 2 | 4 |
Strategy Level | Beginners | Advance |
Reward Profile | Limited | Limited |
Risk Profile | Limited | Limited |
Breakeven Point | Purchase Price of Underlying + Net Premium Paid | Upper Breakeven Point = Strike Price of Highest Strike Short Put - Net Premium Received, Lower Breakeven Point = Strike Price of Lowest Strike Short Put + Net Premium Received |
PROTECTIVE COLLAR Vs SHORT PUT BUTTERFLY - When & How to use ?
PROTECTIVE COLLAR | SHORT PUT BUTTERFLY | |
---|---|---|
Market View | Neutral | Neutral |
When to use? | This Strategy is implemented when the investor requires downside protection for the short - to medium term but at lower cost. | In Short Put Butterfly strategy, a trader is neutral in nature and expects the market to remain range bound in the near future. |
Action | • Short 1 Call Option, • Long 1 Put Option | Sell 1 ITM Put, Buy 2 ATM Put, Sell 1 OTM Put |
Breakeven Point | Purchase Price of Underlying + Net Premium Paid | Upper Breakeven Point = Strike Price of Highest Strike Short Put - Net Premium Received, Lower Breakeven Point = Strike Price of Lowest Strike Short Put + Net Premium Received |
PROTECTIVE COLLAR Vs SHORT PUT BUTTERFLY - Risk & Reward
PROTECTIVE COLLAR | SHORT PUT BUTTERFLY | |
---|---|---|
Maximum Profit Scenario | • Call strike - stock purchase price - net premium paid + net credit received | Net Premium Received - Commissions Paid |
Maximum Loss Scenario | • Stock purchase price - put strike - net premium paid - put strike + net credit received | Strike Price of Higher Strike Short Put - Strike Price of Long Put - Net Premium Received + Commissions Paid |
Risk | Limited | Limited |
Reward | Limited | Limited |
PROTECTIVE COLLAR Vs SHORT PUT BUTTERFLY - Strategy Pros & Cons
PROTECTIVE COLLAR | SHORT PUT BUTTERFLY | |
---|---|---|
Similar Strategies | Bull Put Spread, Bull Call Spread | Short Condor, Reverse Iron Condor |
Disadvantage | • Potential profit is lower or limited. | • High risk strategy and may cause huge losses if the price of the underlying stocks falls steeply. • Higher profit is only possible when shares get close to expiration. |
Advantages | The Risk is limited. | • Benefits from time decay. • Traders can earn more in a rising or range bound scenario. • Benefits from a surge in volatility. |